I used to dislike CM when it was printed on laser printers, but discovered that when it was printed on a Linotype--the Art of Computer Programming books, for instance--it seemed to take on an entirely different character. It looks clean and pretty, rather than spindly.
Clearly that's subjective, and you might hate it no matter the output device. :)
I'm not sure why people like the Computer Modern typeface so much. I think it looks terrible. :\